The Pie Store
The Pie Store in Montclair offers a taste of Britain right in northern New Jersey. The cozy shop is filled with savory meat pies, flaky sausage rolls, and sweet tarts that tempt you from the pastry case. Frozen options make it easy to stock up for quick dinners at home, while shelves carry teas and jams imported from across the pond. It takes about twenty minutes to drive here from Forest Hill, but locals say the buttery crusts and hearty fillings are worth the trip whenever a craving strikes.
Find hours and seasonal specials at thepiestorenj.com.