Mike's Pasta and Sandwich Shop
Mike's Pasta and Sandwich Shop is a hidden gem on Harrison Street in Nutley, offering handmade pasta and hearty Italian sandwiches. The small storefront also stocks sauces, olive oil, and other pantry favorites so you can bring a taste of Italy home. Locals rave about the friendly staff and the generous portions that make every visit satisfying.
The shop is only about a ten minute drive from Forest Hill, making it an easy option when you want quality ingredients without a long trip. Popular picks include the meatball parm hero, tender gnocchi, and the daily specials that showcase whatever fresh pasta is being rolled. It's a perfect stop for grabbing lunch or picking up dinner ingredients on the way home.